Once again our unsuspecting miscreant falls prey to an extremely mischievous Pie Girl, who this time, just happens to be a police officer. Unbeknownst to him, he is about to endure an extremely messy and sticky situation.

He is caught stealing cases of fresh pies and multiple cans of whipped cream. After a brief interrogation, the Police Girl promises him a night of safety if he spends it with her. But how can she possibly dispose of all the evidence?

What he doesn’t know is that this lovely police woman turns into a devilish Pie Girl at night. Her job is to get rid of the evidence of his theft. In what is a wickedly dramatic, delightful and delicious turn of events, she will use all the evidence on him!

She “socks” it to him in the face, dunks his head in a bucket of thick chocolate syrup, and finally she puts him on his knees, hands cuffed behind his back, and blasts him in the face with cake batter pies, frosting pies, blueberry and cherry pies, and chocolate cream and banana cream pies. She doesn’t hold anything back on her handcuffed prisoner.
It is highly unlikely that he will be stealing any more pies from the store.
Originally filmed on Aug. 12, 2001

The Pie Girl - pied by girl pies in the face pie in face guy pied
Guys pied by girl - pie in the face of guy genre