Once again, our unsuspecting miscreant falls prey to an impossibly mischievous Pie Girl—who this time just happens to be a police officer. What begins as a routine arrest quickly spirals into a sticky situation he never saw coming.

Caught red-handed with stolen cases of fresh pies and several cans of whipped cream, he finds himself under interrogation. The Police Girl promises him a night of safety if he spends it with her—but how can she possibly dispose of all the evidence?

What he doesn’t realize is that this lovely officer transforms into a devilish Pie Girl after dark. And her job is simple: use every bit of the evidence… on him.

In a wickedly dramatic and delicious turn of events, she unleashes her messy justice without hesitation. She socks it to him in the face, dunks his head into a bucket of thick chocolate syrup, and then—hands cuffed behind his back—she blasts him with pie after pie: cake batter, frosting, blueberry, cherry, chocolate cream, banana cream… nothing is spared.

She doesn’t hold anything back on her helpless prisoner.

By the end of the night, it’s clear he won't be stealing pies again anytime soon.

Originally filmed on August 12, 2001.